Having read a feel good book previously, I thought I
would continue the trend. I found Tree
Talk by Ana Salote in my library
and decided there wouldn't be anything too horrific or depressing about a child
and a tree. While I was right to think this, the material in the book is
certainly sad in places, but Salote has a knack for juxtaposing the negative
content with the more uplifting and hopeful.
I appreciated the new perspective of a tree. I can't
recall ever reading something from a tree's point of view without it being very
human-esque. From the beginning of the book I found the consciousness of a tree
to be convincing. It was a pleasant idea and easy to grasp. The connection
between child and tree was a touch of necessary magic which allowed the reader
to get into the mind of the tree (or perhaps, it's better described as the tree
being in the mind of a human). This book makes references to oil wars and global
warming, concepts which most people are familiar with. Salote herself says she
wrote this book 'because of human ego-driven planet wrecking. I wanted to give
a voice to the innocent bystanders: the plants and animals'. Well, I think she
succeeded marvellously.
Salote uses language that a child could understand, apart
from a few words that they may need a dictionary or Google to look up the
definition for, and this makes the book accessible. With modern society the way
it is, it seems increasingly important to encourage younger generations to
become aware of the impact their behaviour has on a wider scale. It could be
said that younger readers may not be able to really identify with Charlie
because of the differences in their lifestyles and hobbies, however there are
many similarities in lifestyle and children with a developed imagination will
be able to put themselves in his shoes. Charlie is a character who can set an
example for them. He is kind to plants and animals, and takes an interesting in
protecting life. From an adult perspective Charlie is an endearing little boy.
That certain human 'planet wrecking' isn't explored in
great detail means this book can reach another audience - adults who are tired
of having environmental messages shoved at them left, right and centre. The
animals condemn humans, but there are no hard facts to swallow and no hard guilt
trips for the reader accompanied by a list of what you should do. This allows
the reader to take stock and research things for themselves.
Salote did a great job at creating the plant world. It
was very convincing and enlightening as a reader, despite having studied the science
of plants in my GCSE studies. The animal world was also interesting, but bordered
more on amusing because of the charge leading hamsters and animal strikes. The
ending was also unexpected. The way the ending was delivered seemed abrupt
and yet, at the same time, it extended as far as I would hope it would reach
time wise.
As an adult reader I would have liked more facts
interwoven. I enjoyed how Salote incorporated knowledge such as the origins of
Ash and the importance of trees to the human race. As a fan of learning I would
happily of had more facts like those (as a opposed to numerical facts that can
sound a little preachy and become boring). Furthermore, I felt the disappearance
of Charlie's dad just... happened. I would have expected a little more
development in that department, but I'm aware family and childhood problems
weren't the main focus.
All in all, this story was strangely uplifting. I would recommend
it as it doesn't take long to get through and it doesn't feel emotionally heavy. It's child
friendly and I would certainly suggest encouraging children to read it with an
open mind (and maybe prepared with a bit of background about fossil fuels and
global warming). The friendship between child and tree is fascinating and the
new tree perspective is something I really enjoyed.